Key takeaways
- Lidded ice cube trays compared: one sealing silicone lid, stackable silicone sets, a press-plate bin kit and a compact mini ice box for tight freezers.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
A lid changes an ice cube tray from a spill waiting to happen into something you can carry across the kitchen, stack under frozen peas and pull out at a campsite cooler without a second thought. But “with lid” covers a wide range of designs, and the differences matter more than the cube count on the box. Some lids genuinely seal, most only cover, and a few are really the lid of a storage bin rather than of the tray itself.
Two honesty points before the picks. First, a lid that “prevents spills” usually only guards against sloshing while you carry the tray level to the freezer. It is not a watertight seal for tipping the tray sideways, and several makers say so in their own fine print — where that is the case, it is stated in the Specs below. Only one tray in this lineup has a lid designed to seal well enough for angled storage. Second, cube counts say nothing about how fast a household goes through ice. A 64-cube kit sounds generous until a party works through it in one evening, and a modest 14-cube tray is plenty for a solo camper topping up a water bottle. Match the batch size to your actual use, not to the biggest number.
Every pick below is a cube tray with a lid: stackable silicone sets, two tray-and-bin systems and one single tray with a sealing lid. There are no countertop ice makers and no sphere or novelty molds in the main lineup.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Products were selected on specifications and listing data, not on commission rates.
1. OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray — the one lid that actually seals
The No-Spill is the exception that proves the rule about lids. Its silicone lid is pressed down over the filled tray until it seals, which squeezes out the excess water and lets the tray be carried without drips and stored in the freezer at an angle — OXO rates it for tilted storage up to 45 degrees. That makes it the natural pick for crowded freezers, RV fridges and camp coolers where a tray rarely sits perfectly flat, and the seal also keeps freezer odors away from the ice.
The trade-off is batch size and cube shape. One tray makes 14 cubes, and the rounded cube profile that helps each cube slide out with a press on one end also means the cubes are not the neat squares cocktail drinkers tend to want. The tray body is rigid BPA-free plastic rather than silicone, so release relies on that rounded shape instead of flexing. For a small household, a boat galley or anyone whose freezer is a jigsaw puzzle, the sealing lid is worth more than a bigger batch.
Specs
- Cubes per batch: 14
- Cube size and shape: standard cubes with a rounded base for press-out release
- Tray dimensions: approximately 14.3 x 5.9 x 1 in (listing dimension field: 364 x 149 x 25 mm)
- Weight: 248 g
- Lid: silicone, seals watertight when pressed down; angled storage up to 45 degrees
- Material: BPA-free plastic tray with silicone lid, as listed
- Release method: press one end of each rounded cube; no twisting needed
- Care: top-rack dishwasher safe
2. DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack — the stackable everyday system
DOQAUS sells this set as a small ice system rather than a tray: four silicone trays with lids, a central storage bin with its own lid, and a scoop. Each tray makes 14 cubes of about one fluid ounce, so a full round produces 56 cubes that can be emptied into the bin while the next batch freezes. The trays stack, the flexible silicone bottoms push out one cube at a time, and the whole set is dishwasher safe.
The honesty point sits in DOQAUS’s own listing text: the tray lids have lift tabs and reduce spills while moving, but they allow airflow and are not airtight. Treat them as covers that keep stray freezer debris off the ice and let you stack trays, not as seals. The cubes are also on the small side at roughly an inch, which suits iced coffee, juice and water bottles better than a slow-sipping whiskey. For a family freezer that burns through ice daily, though, the tray-bin-scoop loop is the most practical format here.
Specs
- Cubes per batch: 56 (4 trays x 14)
- Cube size: 27 ml (1 fl oz) per cube, about 1 in
- Set dimensions: 8.2 x 4.5 x 3.6 in as listed for the set
- Weight: 13.7 oz
- Lid: plastic covers with lift tabs; covers only — the maker states the lids are not airtight
- Material: food-grade silicone tray bottoms with polypropylene frames; listed as BPA-free
- Release method: push up from the flexible silicone bottom, one cube at a time
- Included: 4 trays with lids, storage bin with lid, scoop
- Care: dishwasher safe
3. QUELIEN Ice Cube Trays with Bin, Scoop and Press Plate — the party batch
QUELIEN takes the opposite approach to release: instead of flexing a tray, you lay a press plate with 32 small fingers over the frozen tray and push, and a whole tray of cubes drops into the bin at once. Two trays of 32 cells give 64 cubes per round, the highest count in this lineup, and the set stacks into a single bin footprint with a lid on top. For party prep — freezing several rounds ahead and stockpiling in the bin — that one-motion release is genuinely faster than popping cubes individually.
The compromises are cube size and care. The cubes are small, at 0.9 x 0.9 x 0.7 in and about a third of a fluid ounce each, so they chill quickly and melt quickly. The listing marks the set as not dishwasher safe, and the lid is a cover for the bin rather than a seal on the trays, so filled trays still need a level carry to the freezer. Buy it for volume and speed of release, not for slow-melting ice.
Specs
- Cubes per batch: 64 (2 trays x 32)
- Cube size: 0.9 x 0.9 x 0.7 in; 0.31 fl oz (9.3 ml) per cube
- Assembled dimensions: approximately 10.2 x 5.1 x 5.9 in (26 x 13 x 15 cm)
- Weight: 0.83 kg
- Lid: single cover over the storage bin; covers only, not a liquid seal
- Material: plastic trays with silicone cell bottoms; listed as BPA-free
- Release method: press plate that pushes all 32 cubes of a tray out at once
- Included: 2 trays, press plate, storage bin, lid, scoop
- Care: hand wash; listing states not dishwasher safe
4. W&P Mini Ice Box — the compact box for small freezers
The Mini Ice Box shrinks the tray-and-bin idea down to a footprint under six inches square. A single LFGB-certified silicone tray sits on top of a BPA-free plastic box, and the lid snaps onto either the tray while a batch freezes or directly onto the box for storage. The box holds 48 mini cubes, and the small cube size is aimed at narrow-mouth water bottles, mugs and insulated bottles that standard cubes will not fit through.
Because the tray doubles as part of the lid arrangement, the lid is a snap-on cover: it blocks odors and allows stacking, but it is not a liquid seal, so the filled tray still travels flat. The maker’s release routine is to twist and crack the frozen tray, flip it over the box and press the cubes down into storage. For a dorm fridge, an office freezer drawer or a campervan, that self-contained box is easier to live with than loose trays, as long as mini cubes suit your drinks.
Specs
- Capacity: bin holds 48 mini cubes
- Cube size: mini cubes sized for narrow bottle openings (exact cube dimension not published)
- Box dimensions: 5.98 x 5 x 4.49 in
- Weight: 10.08 oz
- Lid: snap-on cover; fits the tray for stacking or the box for storage; covers, does not seal liquid
- Material: LFGB-certified silicone tray; lid and box in BPA-free plastic, as listed
- Release method: twist and crack the tray, then press cubes down into the box
- Care: dishwasher safe
5. PET Hous Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid, Set of 4 — simple stackable trays
Not everyone wants a bin system. This PET Hous set is four plain silicone trays, each with its own snap-on lid, each making 15 cubes of 1.2 in for 60 cubes across the set. The lids let the trays stack without anything resting directly on the ice, the flexible silicone releases cubes with a push or a twist, and the trays have hanging holes so they can air-dry on a hook instead of taking drawer space. It is the closest format here to the classic tray, upgraded with covers.
PET Hous describes the lids as tight-sealing, but they are snap-on silicone lids without a gasket, so the honest reading is the usual one: they guard against sloshing and odors and make stacking safe, and a filled tray tipped sideways will still leak. The listing data also does not publish full tray dimensions — only the 1.2 in cube size — so check that a standard tray footprint suits your freezer shelf before ordering a second set. As a straightforward, freezer-filling basic, it does the job without moving parts.
Specs
- Cubes per batch: 60 (4 trays x 15)
- Cube size: 1.2 x 1.2 x 1.2 in
- Tray dimensions: not published in the listing data; standard single-tray footprint
- Set weight: 1.3 lb
- Lid: snap-on silicone cover on each tray; covers and stacks, not a watertight seal
- Material: silicone; listed as BPA-free
- Release method: flex or push from below, one cube at a time
- Extras: hanging hole in each tray for air-drying
How to choose
Start with the lid, because that is what this category is really about. If your freezer is packed and trays end up tilted, the OXO No-Spill is the only pick here whose lid is designed to seal; everything else needs a level carry and rewards you with bigger batches instead. Next, decide whether you want a bin. The DOQAUS and QUELIEN sets turn ice making into a loop — freeze, empty into the bin, refill — which suits households and party hosts far better than loose trays, while the PET Hous set is simpler and cheaper to expand one tray at a time. The W&P Mini Ice Box is the pick when freezer space, not cube count, is the constraint.
Then check cube size against your glasses. The QUELIEN and W&P cubes are small and fast-melting, made for volume and narrow bottle necks. The DOQAUS one-ounce cubes and the PET Hous 1.2 in cubes are the all-rounders. And keep the headline numbers in perspective: a tray’s cube count tells you the size of one batch, nothing about whether that batch matches how much ice your household actually uses between refills.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialA Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.
See Prime for Young AdultsAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.






Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!